Options After a Defendant Has Been Found Incompetent
Once a court finds a defendant incompetent to proceed, a number of things can happen, some optional, some mandatory, depending on the scenario:
- Regardless of the charges and regardless of restorability, certain persons, such as the District Attorney, may initiate the certification process for civilly committing the defendant. § 16-8.5-111(3). This process is distinct from the criminal case.
- If the highest charge in the case is a class 2 misdemeanor, a petty offense, a drug misdemeanor, or a traffic offense, the court must dismiss the charges. § 16-8.5-111(1.6). Arguably, unclassified misdemeanors, such as DUI, are not subject to this requirement.
- If the court isn’t required to dismiss the charges, before beginning restoration services, you can refer the defendant to a competency diversion program offered by your office or to the Bridges Wraparound Care Program. § 16-8.5-111(2)(a)(II).
- If the court finds, at the time it finds the defendant incompetent, that “there is a substantial probability that the defendant, with restoration services, will attain competency within the reasonably foreseeable future,” the court must order the defendant to restoration services. § 16-8.5-111(2).
If an evaluator opines that there is not a substantial probability that the defendant can be restored to competency within the reasonably foreseeable future, the court must set a hearing on restorability where you must prove the defendant is restorable. § 16-8.5-111(4)(a)(I).
Resources